[Login] or [Signup]
Login
Username:
Password:
[Signup]
[Recover Account]

Navigation

Poll


You must be logged in to view polls
Technical Help > mp3 sourced ?

You are in:  Forums / Technical Help / mp3 sourced ?
Locked
badvokPosted at 2016-01-13 00:00:24(485 wks ago) (Technical Help / mp3 sourced ?)


Uploaded: ---
Downloaded: ---
Posts: 64

Ratio: ---
Location: United Kingdom


what software would you use to see/check if something was mp3 sourced but had been converted to wav or flac ?

Thanks

Report This Post Go to the top of the page
 
toneblokePosted at 2016-01-13 06:17:25(485 wks ago) (Technical Help / mp3 sourced ?)
Remember me !


Uploaded: 1.86 TB
Downloaded: 974.66 GB
Posts: 563

Ratio: 1.96
Location: Australia


Cool Edit Pro
Adobe Audition
Audacity

There are others but these are the usual suspects.


"Look up here, I’m in heaven
I’ve got scars that can’t be seen"
Report This Post Go to the top of the page
 
neilwilkesPosted at 2016-02-02 09:27:17(482 wks ago) (Technical Help / mp3 sourced ?)


Uploaded: 762.30 GB
Downloaded: 638.25 GB
Posts: 756

Ratio: 1.19
Location: United Kingdom


The way I do this is to not waste time looking at spectrum plots as these can be misleading - certain old consoles and even some vinyl has an upper frequency response limitation of 14k400 - you may have seen vinyl with the logo ffss - full frequency stereophonic spectrum, - which has a range of approx 100Hz to 14.40 kHz and a spectral analyzer will try to tell you this is lossy when it is not.
Additionally, some of the old consoles did not have any response above 15kHz.

A surefire way to tell is to check for lossy encoding artifacts. To do this you will need to learn what they sound like, and the best way is to do this:
1 - take any lossless file, ideally ripped from a CD.
2 - Convert this to a 128kbps mp3 file (we are deliberately using a low quality coding to exaggerate the noise so you know what it sounds like)
3 - go to [url]www.voxengo.com[/url] and download the free MSED plugin, install this into your VST plugins folder.
4 - now open the MP3 file in your usual audio editor, and add the MSED plugin.
5 - add a second track containing your lossless original, and again add the MSED plugin
6 - Mute the MID component and pan the Side to both speakers & play the mp3 file.
At this point you are only listening to the spatial information and have muted the centrally panned mono information - you will notice what can only be described as a chirping sound, often described as "Space Monkeys".
7 - for comparison, A/B between the MP3 and the lossless versions, both going through the MSED plugin - the difference - and the noise - will be plainly audible.
Learn this sound & become allergic to it.

Report This Post Go to the top of the page
 
learmDonatedPosted at 2016-02-02 09:56:55(482 wks ago) (Technical Help / mp3 sourced ?)


Uploaded: 757.91 GB
Downloaded: 304.24 GB
Posts: 274

Ratio: 2.49
Location: Germany


Hi Neil, it's great that you are back on the site and also full of energy.
Also it's fantastic to get your professional advice. But I fear to follow this will even cost us more of our (more or less little) remaining lifetime.

Report This Post Go to the top of the page
 
steve23yhPosted at 2016-02-02 11:08:40(482 wks ago) (Technical Help / mp3 sourced ?)
Viceroy


Uploaded: 2.36 TB
Downloaded: 225.86 GB
Posts: 381

Ratio: 10.68
Location: United Kingdom


I know that I'm way way less fussy about MP3 than most others, but if spectrum checks don't work, does it matter?  I guess what I'm saying is, if it isn't obvious that it's MP3-sourced, what difference does it make?


Don't blame me, I didn't do it!
Report This Post Go to the top of the page
 
MBFPosted at 2016-02-02 12:35:52(482 wks ago) (Technical Help / mp3 sourced ?)


Uploaded: 1,002.89 GB
Downloaded: 232.55 GB
Posts: 685

Ratio: 4.31
Location: United Kingdom


steve23yh wrote:

I know that I'm way way less fussy about MP3 than most others, but if spectrum checks don't work, does it matter?  I guess what I'm saying is, if it isn't obvious that it's MP3-sourced, what difference does it make?

And so the debate between lossless and MP3's rages on... :D

Personally I'd say none but it presumably depends on what you listen to it on. If you are an audiophile and play the tracks through an expensive sound system then I'd guess that it would be noticeable say when compared to listening to it on an iPhone through headphones. However, I am no expert here of course and this is just MHO.

I do prefer Flac or Wav format but downsize to MP3 when playing on my own very cheap and old MP3 player.

Report This Post Go to the top of the page
 
surflingDonatedPosted at 2016-02-02 12:43:19(482 wks ago) (Technical Help / mp3 sourced ?)


Uploaded: 204.00 GB
Downloaded: 100.49 GB
Posts: 106

Ratio: 2.03
Location: Barbados


trader's little helper checks for mp3 sourced files and works fairly well, quick and easy i'd say.

it's a fantastic tool to have anyway, doing flac conversions, removing SBEs etc, and - it's free  :-)

Report This Post Go to the top of the page
 
paperdragonPosted at 2016-02-02 14:16:31(482 wks ago) (Technical Help / mp3 sourced ?)
Fomer Admin RIP


Uploaded: 3.03 TB
Downloaded: 4.86 TB
Posts: 556

Ratio: 0.62
Location: Turkey


Quote:

I guess what I'm saying is, if it isn't obvious that it's MP3-sourced, what difference does it make?

The equipment I trust far more than any other is simply my ears. I've never cared what various testing programs showed - all that matters to me is how it sounds.

That said, I've always thought that MP3s sounded pretty bad.


...and then my mind split open.
Report This Post Go to the top of the page
 
neilwilkesPosted at 2016-02-02 14:18:03(482 wks ago) (Technical Help / mp3 sourced ?)


Uploaded: 762.30 GB
Downloaded: 638.25 GB
Posts: 756

Ratio: 1.19
Location: United Kingdom


MBF wrote:

steve23yh wrote:

I know that I'm way way less fussy about MP3 than most others, but if spectrum checks don't work, does it matter?  I guess what I'm saying is, if it isn't obvious that it's MP3-sourced, what difference does it make?

And so the debate between lossless and MP3's rages on... :D Personally I'd say none but it presumably depends on what you listen to it on. If you are an audiophile and play the tracks through an expensive sound system then I'd guess that it would be noticeable say when compared to listening to it on an iPhone through headphones. However, I am no expert here of course and this is just MHO.I do prefer Flac or Wav format but downsize to MP3 when playing on my own very cheap and old MP3 player.

I understand the point, I really do - but for me the problem is that I can hear the artifacts now I know what to listen for, and so can anyone - it is just a matter of training your ears.
That said, some alleged "audiophile" downloads are a con, pure & simple. A classic example is the very expensive DSD version of "Reality" available for somewhere around £18 that is a straight DSD encoding of the 1`6/44.1 files!!

Report This Post Go to the top of the page
 
MBFPosted at 2016-02-02 20:59:19(482 wks ago) (Technical Help / mp3 sourced ?)


Uploaded: 1,002.89 GB
Downloaded: 232.55 GB
Posts: 685

Ratio: 4.31
Location: United Kingdom


neilwilkes wrote:

but for me the problem is that I can hear the artifacts now I know what to listen for

Yup, can see (hear?!) that. Once you know or learn something then it's difficult not to see or hear it again.

Last edited by MBF on 2016-02-02 20:59:25


Report This Post Go to the top of the page
 
steve23yhPosted at 2016-02-02 21:50:23(482 wks ago) (Technical Help / mp3 sourced ?)
Viceroy


Uploaded: 2.36 TB
Downloaded: 225.86 GB
Posts: 381

Ratio: 10.68
Location: United Kingdom


I'm always way way too busy listening to the songs!


Don't blame me, I didn't do it!
Report This Post Go to the top of the page
 
willb3dPosted at 2016-02-02 23:07:49(482 wks ago) (Technical Help / mp3 sourced ?)


Uploaded: 282.62 GB
Downloaded: 249.96 GB
Posts: 111

Ratio: 1.13
Location: United States of America


Easiest if you are on a Mac to just download "Spek".

You just drag a music file onto it and a couple seconds later it shows you where the cut-off occurs.

After seeing a few examples you quickly understand what you are seeing - from the basics of how high quality (say, 320kbps) mp3 sourced material extends on up to 20 kHz, how lossless sourced material usually extends to 22 kHz, how low quality mp3s or YouTube sourced audio can cut off way down around 17 kHz, to more complex things like how you can spot television-sourced material by the tight band of color that goes across near the top third (which I guess is a carrier signal or something inaudible but quite noticeable visually).

It's really easy, and since it is a tiny program, it's worth trying.

It's at http://spek.cc

Recently I noticed you can even drop most VIDEO files onto it, and it will show you the audio. So no need to do anything complex. Literally just drop the file on to see the result.

Last edited by willb3d on 2016-02-02 23:09:00


Report This Post Go to the top of the page
 
toneblokePosted at 2016-02-03 06:45:37(482 wks ago) (Technical Help / mp3 sourced ?)
Remember me !


Uploaded: 1.86 TB
Downloaded: 974.66 GB
Posts: 563

Ratio: 1.96
Location: Australia


The whole story behind quality lossless audio isn't necessarily about listening as an audiophile (which I am not). The serious ROIO collectors/traders prefer the good stuff so that 1: when a show is traded or acquired you know you are getting quality files; 2: with these lossless files, as originated, the trading pool isn't filled up with a myriad of compressed/remixed/remastered/adjusted/resampled crap.
Yes, even a lossy based capture can sound good but, as a collector, if you have the option of getting files at 24/96 lossless as opposed to 320 Kbps mp3 then it's no question.


"Look up here, I’m in heaven
I’ve got scars that can’t be seen"
Report This Post Go to the top of the page
 
neilwilkesPosted at 2016-02-03 09:00:10(482 wks ago) (Technical Help / mp3 sourced ?)


Uploaded: 762.30 GB
Downloaded: 638.25 GB
Posts: 756

Ratio: 1.19
Location: United Kingdom


willb3d wrote:

Easiest if you are on a Mac to just download "Spek". You just drag a music file onto it and a couple seconds later it shows you where the cut-off occurs.After seeing a few examples you quickly understand what you are seeing - from the basics of how high quality (say, 320kbps) mp3 sourced material extends on up to 20 kHz, how lossless sourced material usually extends to 22 kHz, how low quality mp3s or YouTube sourced audio can cut off way down around 17 kHz, to more complex things like how you can spot television-sourced material by the tight band of color that goes across near the top third (which I guess is a carrier signal or something inaudible but quite noticeable visually). It's really easy, and since it is a tiny program, it's worth trying.It's at http://spek.ccRecently I noticed you can even drop most VIDEO files onto it, and it will show you the audio. So no need to do anything complex. Literally just drop the file on to see the result.

The Carrier you are referring to is usually at around 15k6 and can also be introduced by early SSL consoles with the built-in monitors so again things are not always what they seem to be - this is the problem with looking at an audio file rather than listening to it.

Report This Post Go to the top of the page
 
willb3dPosted at 2016-02-04 22:48:59(481 wks ago) (Technical Help / mp3 sourced ?)


Uploaded: 282.62 GB
Downloaded: 249.96 GB
Posts: 111

Ratio: 1.13
Location: United States of America


neilwilkes wrote:

The Carrier you are referring to is usually at around 15k6 and can also be introduced by early SSL consoles with the built-in monitors so again things are not always what they seem to be - this is the problem with looking at an audio file rather than listening to it.

Sure but if you see that line but also see frequencies up high, you know you're not looking at a television source. Eventually you just recognize what is what.

It's just easier for some people to judge visually than by using one's ears, especially if one is trying to decide which set of files to keep if both sound essentially the same.

Sure I do listening too, keeping my head in the same position because I'm aware that even moving your position completely changes one's perception of the sound from one's speakers. It's helpful, but not easy, to rely only on one's impression.



Last edited by willb3d on 2016-02-04 22:51:27


Report This Post Go to the top of the page
 
neilwilkesPosted at 2016-02-05 11:38:23(481 wks ago) (Technical Help / mp3 sourced ?)


Uploaded: 762.30 GB
Downloaded: 638.25 GB
Posts: 756

Ratio: 1.19
Location: United Kingdom


Another instant CD tester is TAU analyzer.
This uses an algorithm to check for CDDA or lossy source and it also throws out a spectral plot if you really need one. The only downside is that is only checks a CD - not files.

Report This Post Go to the top of the page
 

<< Prev  1   Next >>

Locked
You are not permitted to post in this forum.

Latest Forum Posts
Latest Topic TitleRepliesViewsAuthorLast Post
Images Vol. 212192homebrewby Moony
2025-04-30 20:53:01
40th Anniversary Picture Disc Collection - Mixcloud Playlist123562libertine90by professormouse
2025-04-30 09:17:54
Ready Set Go source?10573Besomdaveby professormouse
2025-04-30 09:15:15
Health Issues28725Steveboyby StarmanPhilly
2025-04-30 02:22:27
part 2 radio 2 celebrates089Diedrichby Diedrich
2025-04-29 19:41:54
Exploring Bowie (1969-1986)71164Rael076by professormouse
2025-04-22 04:16:24
The Collector vinyl3460Rael076by Rael076
2025-04-21 02:02:36
Images Vol. 200427homebrewby homebrew
2025-04-19 14:47:52
Hello!71399daydreamby neilwilkes
2025-04-18 13:40:24
Halloween Jack Is A Real Cool Cat CD/DVD14666gousterby themole
2025-04-17 05:52:28
Images Vol. 190430homebrewby homebrew
2025-04-06 18:49:45
Images Vol. 181635homebrewby professormouse
2025-04-04 18:49:07
Images Vol. 1721146homebrewby Moony
2025-03-23 19:37:14


Online Users

Newest Members
Modified by JanErik |- Page Generated In 0.061784 secs.
-|- RSS Feed -|- Feed Info
Theme Base By: Nikkbu | Modified by: paperdragon | Graphics by: MossGarden
Email: bowiestation(AT)bowiestation.com